Good Peanut Butter Pie – The Keep At Residence Chef

Expertise the magic of a wonderfully made peanut butter pie. This pie is creamy, wealthy, and stuffed to the brim with peanut butter. It’s certain to be successful!

There’s one thing undeniably alluring a few well-made peanut butter pie. Its creamy texture mixed with the wealthy flavors of peanut butter and chocolate is a match made in dessert heaven. This pie brings collectively the consolation of basic elements and the enjoyment of a deal with that’s excellent for any event.

Continuously Requested Questions

Is that this recipe no-bake?

Sure and no. You’ll should bake your Oreo crust, however you don’t should bake once more when you’ve added the filling.

Can I make the crust and not using a meals processor?

Completely! Whereas a meals processor makes the job faster, you may as well use a rolling pin to crush the cookies inside a sealed plastic bag.

Do I want Cool Whip or cream cheese?

Some peanut butter pie recipes name for extra elements like Cool Whip and cream cheese for the filling. Our home made model is made with heavy whipping cream as a substitute. The outcomes are a thick and creamy pie filling with none Cool Whip or added cream cheese! 

Do I’ve to make use of a microwave for the peanut butter combination?

No, you may soften it on the stovetop utilizing a double boiler methodology.

What peanut butter is finest for this pie?

Whereas we love spreading all-natural PB on our morning toast, you’re going to wish to select a basic creamy or chunky PB like Jif or Skippy for this peanut butter pie recipe. The all-natural varieties don’t have sufficient added oil in them to provide the consistency you’re after for the filling. 

How lengthy does this dessert take to set?

Persistence is a advantage and also you’ll want it for this recipe. After you’ve baked your crust and added your filling, it’s essential to let the pie set utterly earlier than serving. Place it in your fridge for at the least 6 hours.

If you happen to can let it set in a single day, even higher!


  • Oreo Cookies: Use gluten-free Oreo cookies for the crust if desired.
  • Butter: Go for refined coconut oil or a plant-based butter substitute.
  • Selfmade whipped cream: Use a store-bought dairy or plant-based whipped cream as a substitute of creating it from scratch, if desired.

Whipped Cream Stabilizers

Nobody likes a tragic, runny peanut butter pie, which is why we’ve included dry milk powder with the whipping cream to solidify for the right texture. Different choices for whipped cream stabilizers:

  • Xantham Gum: Use 1/4 teaspoon per cup of whipping cream.
  • Gelatin: You have to put together your gelatin earlier than including to cream. Add 1 teaspoon of gelatin to 1 tablespoon of chilly water. Let stand for five minutes to thicken earlier than melting within the microwave for just some seconds till it turns into liquid. 
  • Guar Gum: Use as much as 1 teaspoon per cup of chilly whipping cream
  • King Arthur Flour’s Whipped Cream Stabilizer: Use 1-2 tablespoons per cup of whipping cream

Topping Concepts

We extremely advocate chopped peanut butter cups and a drizzle of chocolate syrup excessive of your pie. It’s also possible to add:

  • Chocolate chips
  • Melted drizzled peanut butter
  • Peanut butter candies (like Reese’s Items or Peanut Butter M&M’s)
  • Peanut butter chips
  • Whipped cream


  • Crumbly Crust: Make sure you’ve added sufficient butter to bind the crumbs. Press firmly when setting the crust.
  • Filling Gained’t Set: Be certain that to whip the cream to stiff peaks and permit sufficient refrigeration time. Utilizing full-fat elements may also assist obtain the proper consistency.

Suggestions From the Chef

  • Guarantee your whipping cream is chilly; it helps obtain stiff peaks quicker.
  • For an excellent crust, use the again of a spoon to press down the cookie combination firmly.
  • Permit the pie to set within the fridge for just a few hours earlier than serving, making certain a firmer texture.
A slice of peanut butter pie with a bite removed.

Freezing Directions

If you happen to resolve to make your peanut butter pie forward of time for an upcoming occasion, you may freeze it to maintain it recent. Be certain that to wrap it very tightly with plastic wrap earlier than inserting it inside your freezer. It’s going to maintain for as much as 1 month. Let it thaw within the fridge in a single day earlier than serving!

Storage Directions

Retailer leftovers within the fridge in an hermetic container, or just wrap the pie dish tightly with plastic wrap. The leftovers will maintain for about 3 days within the fridge.

Extra Favourite Pie Recipes

Watch the video beneath the place Caytlin will stroll you thru each step of this recipe. Generally it helps to have a visible, and we’ve all the time bought you lined with our cooking present. You’ll find the whole assortment of recipes on YouTube, Facebook Watch, or our Facebook Page, or proper right here on our web site with their corresponding recipes.

Trending Merchandise

Add to compare
Xbox Series X Replica Mini Fridge Thermoelectric Cooler, 10 Liters

Xbox Series X Replica Mini Fridge Thermoelectric Cooler, 10 Liters

Add to compare
Zevro Compact Dry Food Dispenser, Dual Control, Black/Chrome

Zevro Compact Dry Food Dispenser, Dual Control, Black/Chrome


We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Register New Account
Compare items
  • Total (0)
Shopping cart